To leave a comment

To leave a comment, please click on the title of the post to leave or read all comments and replies. Thank you :)

Be sure to scroll down the page today

Be sure to scroll down the page

There are TWO posts today...Sorry about that :)

Sunday, December 27, 2009

Review: Searching for Pemberley by Mary Lydon Simonsen

Author: Mary Lydon Simonsen
Publisher: Sourcebooks Landmark
Genre: Fiction, historical, romance
Trade Paperback, 496 pages
Book Source: Sourcebooks

From Sourcebooks:

Set against Regency England, World Wars I and II, and postwar England, three love stories intertwine in surprising and fateful ways.

American Maggie Joyce, touring Derbyshire in 1947, visits, Montclair, an 18th century Georgian country house, that she is told was the model for Jane Austen's Pemberley. More amazingly, the former residents of the mansion, William Lacey and Elizabeth Garrison, were the inspiration for the characters of Fitzwilliam Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet in Pride and Prejudice.

Through letters, diary entries, and oral history, Beth and Jack Crowell, a couple who lives in the nearby village of Crofton, share stories of the people they say inspired Jane Austen. They also tell their own love story, made difficult by their vastly different backgrounds—she was one of the social elite while he was the son of a servant. When their son, Michael, travels home from his RAF station in Malta, Maggie may have just found her very own Mr. Darcy.

My Thoughts:

This book is much more than a Pride and Prejudice re-imagined, or continuation of the story. It takes the view that Austen was inspired by real events, relates that inspiration, and along the way tells the story of people living and growing up in England during two world wars. The author also explains Maggie's background and her life growing up in a coal mining town. Again, another tough way to live, but people did it and still do.

This story is fashioned in such a way that the reader forgets they are reading an Austen inspired book. I became wrapped up in the stories of the characters. The British are quite tenacious and let nothing stand in their way. I was transported to the past. Between food rationing and the immigrant experience in America, it became quite clear to me, that I am lucky to be living now. Simonsen clearly did her research, and relates these historical experiences into a great story.

There are indeed three love stories, and possibly four if you count Maggie's relationship with an American airman. Through him the reader learns what it was like to be a bombardier. It is not pretty folks. It is very sad and it amazes me that these young men were able to come back home and lead normal lives, for the most part. As a matter of fact, Maggie has two men vying for her heart; both airmen, one American one British. Two men in uniform, my word.

The only negative I have, is that in the beginning of the story, I was a bit confused between the characters from Austen's story and the real life inspirations. Simonsen does provide background on Austen's characters and who they are in real life, with some background in case you haven't read the original P&P. I was still a little confused at times but it passed quickly.

Overall this was a very enjoyable and engrossing story. I lost myself reading this story, and empathized with each and every character, along with their trials and tribulations. I just wanted to make them all a cup of tea.

My Rating: 98/100. Loved it!!!

Thanks to Danielle from Sourcebooks for my review copy.

Challenges Met: Everything Austen Challenge 2009


Blodeuedd said...

wow really loving this one I see, then it is good enough for me :)

Ash said...

I keep hearing about this book but I have been so confused about what it is actually about. Great review- I might have to check it out!

The Bookworm said...

wow, this sounds very good! pride and prejudice is one of my favorites, and i'm always interested in books that are inspired by it.

Teddyree said...

Now this one sounds wonderful, it's going on my wishlist, thanks to your review :-)

Laura Hartness said...

Glad you liked it! I just won a copy in a contest and it's on the way. Looking forward to it.

Thanks for stopping by my blog today!

Laura Hartness
The Calico Critic

Staci said...

98!!!!!!!!!!! I so have to get this one from the library!! Loved your review!!

Marg said...

Sounds like I haven't read far enough then. I started this book and was really struggling with it, and was in fact a little disappointed as so far it isn't what I thought it was going to be. Will keep reading.

Mary Simonsen said...

Thank you, Jen, for your wonderful review and for all those who commented. You have a terrific blog.

teabird said...

Wonderful review of a book that I must read. (sigh - my tbr pile groweth....)

Jem said...

Thanks for the review. It sounds like a book worth reading. I love the cover! Happy New Year Jenny Girl.

Toni said...

This is my must have book. I have been enjoying the reviews and author interviews around blogland. Thanks for the review. 98 is great!!

Jenny Girl said...

Thank you for all your kind comments Ladies!

Marg: Stick with it. It is tough in the beginning but once you get past that and realize it's much more than an Austen re-do, or continuation of the story, I think you'll like it. That's the aspect that took me by surprise and I enjoyed the most.

Ash: It's not what you are thinking and that is why I liked it so much. It's def different.

Teabird: Sorry for making your pile grow! I know the feeling.

Linda: you are too good.

Naida: P&P is one of my favs too, all of the movie versions in their own unique way.

Teddy and Staci: Thank you!

Laura: Congratulations!

Mary: Thank you and thank you for the good book!

Jemima: I really like the cover too. Nice and soft and only hints at what is underneath.

Toni: Thank you! It's a sweet story and I think it suits you.

Mary Simonsen said...

Again, my thanks to Jen and to all those who commented. It is appreciated. Mary

Anonymous said... this review. Sounds like a great book.

Anonymous said...

I'm so glad you loved it cause I just won this and it's sitting on my shelf asking to be read :)

Post a Comment

Thank you very much for leaving me a comment. I know you may be pressed for time, and I appreciate you taking a few minutes to leave your thoughts.
I enjoy reading all of them. Thanks again and have a great day :)