To leave a comment

To leave a comment, please click on the title of the post to leave or read all comments and replies. Thank you :)

Be sure to scroll down the page today

Be sure to scroll down the page

There are TWO posts today...Sorry about that :)

Saturday, August 11, 2012

Final Review: The Stand by Stephen King



This is my final review post for The Stand...along hosted by Trish at Love, Laughter, and a Touch of Insanity.  Please stop by this post to see what others thought, because seriously, I am sure no one will be as negative as me.  Also, you'll probably get better reviews and thoughts there.
Lets get to it, shall we?  

In Short:  The Stand is literally the stand between good and evil when only a handful of people are left in the world due to a catastrophe.  what choices will you make?

Why I read/listened:
I was super excited to read The Stand for several reasons.  Always wanted to....one of those books you are just supposed to have read....give King another chance with me.  Also, I figured reading with friends would help me to get through the book, and the read along certainly did that.

Thoughts in General: I totally enjoyed the first half of the book.  Didn't want to put it down, was interested in what happened to most of the characters, enjoyed the journey they were taking to get to Mother Abigail.  Then they left Nebraska and headed to Boulder, Colorado, and that's when everything fell apart for me.  Once the Free Zone was started everyone started to bore me to tears.  My knitting sister, with whom I discuss books, asked me how The Stand was going and that's when I realized, I did not like any of these people any more.  The characters became two dimensional, were never going to grow (except for Larry), and I wished they were all dead.  If I lived in the Free Zone, I would have left.  I thought the plot came to a screaching halt and that's why I considered not finishing.  But...I pushed forward and skimmed my way to the end.

The book is long. Way too long.  I had the uncut version, but I'm not sure that would have mattered.  

Is The Stand scary? Today in 2012, not so much, but back when it was originally published, probably.  Makes you think though what would you do in this type of situation.  Better learn how to ride a motorcycle or at least a Vespa.  And have good walking shoes.  And know how to defend yourself.


Major Spoilers:  As much as I hated


The one quote I marked:  I have nothing for this.  I'm not usually a quote marker so it has to be really good and stand out for me to mark it.

Bottom Line: I am glad I finally read this book, and this read-along was the push I needed.  This is a classic good vs evil story and many people enjoy it, just not me.  I was surprised by how much religion was in this story.  Good vs evil, religion should be par for the course, I understand that, but I was surprised by King's religious side.  Captain Tripps was this century's version of the Great Flood, and after everything settled down, mankind started to go back to it's old ways, as discussed at the end of the book, with an armed police force being required, etc.  History always repeats itself people.

btw, Trish said something about taking us two-stepping.  I'm so there.  I even own a pair of cowboy boots so I'm set :)

Serious Bottom Line: Well I wanted almost everyone in the book to die, so there's that.  However, mostly everyone else really enjoyed the book.  Part of me doesn't think the narrative aged well, but since it's good vs evil, how can that be?  Some elements felt dated, like Frannie and her story.  Otherwise, people struggling and trying to come together to survive, that story will never get old.


 Have you ever read The Stand?  Thoughts?


My Rating: 79/100 (since the first half was riveting)
Publisher: Doubleday
Genre: horror, dystopian
Paperback, 1141  pages
Book Source: Paperbackswap

 © Jenny Girl - 2012 "All Rights Reserved"

Comments (19)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Thats too bad you didnt enjoy the last half of the story. I know King tends to drag things on. Good for you on reading this one though. I haven't attempted it yet. Maybe when I'm caught up on reviews I'll attempt a long King novel.
1 reply · active 656 weeks ago
I would recommend the shortened version. The one part i know that was cut, does not enhance the reading experience.
I have to say "ditto" I didn't even bother posting a review. I finished, but I REALLY had to push myself. Never have I wanted to quit a book as much as this one, oh well maybe "running with scissors" would have been equally unlikeable for me. But you are right, the book would certainly have made a bigger splash when it was first published, and way too long.
1 reply · active 656 weeks ago
Here, here Irene! We are two peas in a pod on this one. But that's not stopping me from one more King novel.
O strong opinions. Great review. I've never read or listened to it but I should some day. I wonder if there is an audio abridged.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
2 replies · active 655 weeks ago
There prob is an abridged version, so def look for that. Or wait util Ben Afflack puts out his new version.
He's working on that? Coool! Thanks for the news/tip.
I read this when I finished high school I think and to be honest I remember very little about it, I think I enjoyed it. Mind you my taste back then probably wasn't as discerning and I had a lot more time for long winded-ness LOL. Some books just don't stand the test of time but yay you for getting through a major chunkster.
1 reply · active 656 weeks ago
lol you are prob correct Teddy. I was much more patient in my younger days too :)
Oh, no! I'm so sorry you didn't enjoy it! :( But, glad you were able to push through it! I have read that the original, edited version (-400 pages) is a lot better all around, so when I do end up reading it again one day, I'm opting for the shorter version! If we can call 700 pages "shorter." :)
1 reply · active 656 weeks ago
700 pages is definitely shorter! Its ok that I didn't like it. I had that feeling but the beginning was so good! Oh well at least I finally read it!
Some day I'm going to tackle this book but I may listen to it instead of reading. Maybe that would help to get through it since it's so long. I'm glad you made it through!
1 reply · active 656 weeks ago
You listening prob would make this better, with a good narrator of course.
I read the original version, not the uncut and I think it did make a big difference on length. It didn't feel nearly as long for me as it seems it did for everyone else and it's about 400 pages shorter.
1 reply · active 656 weeks ago
I know of one scene or part that was cut, and I could have done without it also. It did nothing for the over all story. (Trashcan Man and the Kidd's journey and all of that)
i wonder what else is cut?

Oh well, always best to go for the cut version i guess.
Now that I'm reading this I can't believe you are gung ho for the It readalong!
3 replies · active 653 weeks ago
Uh not really....I'm a little over 200 pages into IT and bored to tears my friend. I'm giving IT until 300 and then I'll make my decision.
Jen,
I'm only about 125 in and have just started to like it. Don't know if it will last. I've got to think that with over 1000 pages I'm gonna wanna quit at least once.

stacy
Stacy,
as you can see I am quite behind in my blogging etc. �I have already quit the book �Got 300 pages in and i felt that was enough for me. �
Still like little Gage clown though ;) �That phot on your blog was priceless

Post a new comment

Comments by